Ebook The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier
Downloading guide The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier in this website lists could make you a lot more benefits. It will certainly reveal you the most effective book collections as well as completed collections. A lot of books can be found in this web site. So, this is not just this The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier Nonetheless, this publication is described read because it is an impressive book to provide you a lot more opportunity to get experiences as well as thoughts. This is easy, check out the soft file of guide The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier as well as you get it.
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier
Ebook The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier
The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier. The established innovation, nowadays assist every little thing the human requirements. It consists of the everyday activities, jobs, office, home entertainment, and more. Among them is the wonderful net link and also computer system. This problem will relieve you to sustain among your hobbies, reviewing habit. So, do you have going to review this book The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier now?
This publication The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier is expected to be one of the most effective vendor book that will certainly make you really feel completely satisfied to buy and also review it for finished. As known could typical, every book will have certain things that will certainly make a person interested a lot. Even it comes from the writer, kind, content, and even the author. Nonetheless, many individuals likewise take the book The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier based on the motif as well as title that make them surprised in. and below, this The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier is very advised for you because it has appealing title and style to read.
Are you really a follower of this The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier If that's so, why do not you take this publication currently? Be the first person which such as and lead this book The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier, so you can obtain the reason and messages from this publication. Don't bother to be confused where to get it. As the various other, we discuss the link to visit as well as download the soft file ebook The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier So, you could not carry the printed book The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier everywhere.
The existence of the online book or soft data of the The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier will relieve people to obtain guide. It will certainly likewise save more time to just search the title or author or publisher to get until your publication The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier is exposed. After that, you could visit the link download to visit that is given by this internet site. So, this will be an excellent time to begin appreciating this publication The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier to review. Constantly great time with book The Myth Of The Great War: A New Military History Of World War I, By John Mosier, consistently good time with cash to invest!
Based on previously unused French and German sources, this challenging and controversial new analysis of the war on the Western front from 1914 to 1918 reveals how and why the Germans won the major battles with one-half to one-third fewer casualties than the Allies, and how American troops in 1918 saved the Allies from defeat and a negotiated peace with the Germans.
- Sales Rank: #267006 in Books
- Published on: 2002-07-30
- Released on: 2002-07-30
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.00" h x .90" w x 5.31" l, .74 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 400 pages
From Publishers Weekly
In reading and analyzing the great body of tactical and operational literature published by French soldiers and academicians in the interwar period, Loyola English professor and film critic Mosier, who is fluent in French, brings to light a perspective generally neglected by historians who prefer to tell the war's story from a German or British view. For most of WWI, Mosier reminds us, it was the French who held most of the front and did most of the dying. In contrast to the German army's systematic success at technical and tactical innovation, Mosier finds that French and British generals "solved" battlefield problems by throwing shells and bodies at them, then concealing the gruesome results from their governments and their people. Allied victory, he argues, depended on an American Expeditionary Force whose commander, Gen. John J. Pershing, saw through the pretensions of his counterparts in command, and insisted on fighting the war in his own way. While Mosier's argument is eloquently presented, scholars of the period will find it consistently spoiled by overstatement; the German army of WWI as described by most historians is nothing like the tempered and perfected instrument described in these pages, and Mosier's notion of Verdun as a German victory was not likely to be found in the ranks or the headquarters of the divisions who fought there. Still, this is the best narrative account in English of the Franco-German combat in central and in southern France from the aftermath of the Marne in 1914 to the end of Verdun in 1916. Buffs and scholars will take note, but the detailed maps, charts and technical focus will put off generalists.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Mosier (English, Loyola Univ.) offers a scathing indictment of the Allied military mindset that caused so many senseless deaths on the Western Front during the Great War. For example, Mosier argues that it took the slaughter of thousands of infantrymen before the British and French commands tried to use artillery as an effective offensive weapon. Even then, Allied artillery bombardments never matched their opponents' effective use of heavy-caliber howitzers. Mosier points out that from the very beginning the German General Staff attempted to minimize losses by making firepower central to its offensive tactics. Consequently, German casualties were half those of the Allies. Blind adherence to antiquated military doctrines is not a new criticism of Allied generalship, but Mosier's original scholarship does offer a fresh perspective on an old theme. Recommended for public and academic libraries with strong military history collections. Jim Doyle, Sara Hightower Regional Lib., Rome, GA
Copyright 2001 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
According to Mosier, many standard battle accounts of World War I give too much credit to the woefully inadequate commanders and armies of France and Britain. In comparison, the German generals and forces were better trained and equipped. Technologically advanced and tactically superior, the Germans sustained far fewer casualties and experienced considerably more offensive victories than the Allies. After dissecting the major campaigns on the western front, Mosier concludes that Germany's ultimate defeat was the direct result of the influx of American soldiers into France in 1917 and 1918. The American Expeditionary Force, led by its own commanding officers, who wisely defied or ignored French and British strategy and advice, was almost exclusively responsible for the eventual outcome of the conflict. This is revisionist history that convincingly smashes the myths that Allied governments, leaders, and propagandists worked so hard to promulgate. Mosier's masterful account is a welcome addition to the number of recent books that are reviving interest in World War I. Margaret Flanagan
Copyright � American Library Association. All rights reserved
Most helpful customer reviews
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Interesting book!
By Carson H.
Awesome book with a lot of information. Would read again!
11 of 17 people found the following review helpful.
Get it from the Library
By Brian Asalone
This book should not be the only book you read about WWI. It is a biased viewpoint of American prowess, German tactical capability and French and British incompetence. The good part of the book is in the beginning where the author goes into some detail about German tactics and especially the artillery used. He contrasts this mainly with the French, and uses some battles to illustrate the results. All this was enlightening and interesting. But (as several other reviewers have suggested) Mosier goes too far. He implies that the French barely learned as the war went on, that the Marne was not the victory/setback it really was, that the British remained almost uselessly incompetent. Further when he describes the American effort, he exaggerates the psychologic and tactical effect of the American efforts. He minimalizes the concurrent efforts of the Allies and neglects to examine the German state of affairs (exhaustion) after four long years of war. You get the impression that only the Americans could beat this German juggernaut. But even Mosier relates that the Americans were using French equipment and French as opposed to British training (although he partially explains away the former).
14 of 26 people found the following review helpful.
A Controversial Premise - But Required Reading
By John G. Gleeson Sr.
Prof. Mosier's premise that the German Army was superior to those of the Alllies, and that its tactical doctrine would have won the war, but for the intervention of the United States, is controversial, but not new. ( see, Goodspeed, "The German Wars", and, Dupuy, "A Genius For War -The German Army and General Staff, 1807-1945") Mosier concentrates his analysis on the Western Front and on matters strictly military, and thus we lose the impact of the British Navy's blockade on the economic destruction of Germany. However, his analysis of Allied Command and his focus on their horrible lack of strategic integrity is on the mark. He argues that while the Allied Command itself caused the destruction of the French and British Armies, they controlled the flow of information from the battlefield to the extent that most histories of the War are derived from highly flawed and frequently false data. There is ample support for his position in existing histories of the War when the reader focuses on the timing of events, the Allied refusal to cease frontal assaults on fortified positions, and the casualty figures for the respective armies. Perhaps this is an object lesson about the risk connected with winners writing history; they have a great opportunity to "clean up" their mistakes for posterity. Mosier also writes in a very lucid and organized manner, and the maps and footnotes are both helpful in understanding and supportive of his premise. I view this as essential reading for anyone who has an interest in the First World War, or in the evolution of battlefield tactics.
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier PDF
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier EPub
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier Doc
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier iBooks
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier rtf
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier Mobipocket
The Myth of the Great War: A New Military History of World War I, by John Mosier Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment